WordPress vs Shopify | Accessibility Face-Off 2025
Choosing the right content management system (CMS) makes a huge difference for website accessibility. With over 1 billion people worldwide living with disabilities, picking a platform that supports creating accessible websites directly affects your ability to welcome all users. In 2025, both WordPress and Shopify have made strides in accessibility, but they take different approaches. This article compares how these popular platforms handle accessibility in their core features, default themes, and through third-party additions. We’ll examine which platform gives you the better foundation for creating an ADA-compliant, accessible website that works for everyone.
Accessibility Fundamentals in Content Management Systems
When evaluating a CMS platform for accessibility, there are several key areas to check. First, the default themes should follow accessibility standards out of the box. Second, the administrative dashboard needs to work for site managers with disabilities. Third, the platform should make it easy to maintain accessibility as you add content and features.
Both WordPress and Shopify claim to prioritize accessibility, but the real test is how they perform against established standards. Let’s break down how these platforms measure up in 2025.
Regulatory Requirements for CMS Platforms
Content management systems don’t exist in a vacuum – they need to help site owners meet legal requirements for accessibility. These include:
- WCAG 2.2 Guidelines: The current technical standard for web accessibility, with requirements at levels A, AA, and AAA
- ADA Compliance: U.S. law requiring websites to be accessible to people with disabilities
- Section 508: Requirements for federal websites and organizations receiving federal funding
- European Accessibility Act: EU requirements taking effect in June 2025
Both WordPress and Shopify reference these standards in their documentation, but implementation varies significantly. WordPress explicitly states in their accessibility statement that they aim for WCAG 2.2 AA compliance in core features and bundled themes. Shopify also references WCAG compliance in their accessibility conformance reports for themes like Dawn.
Shopify Accessibility in 2025
Shopify has positioned itself as a leading e-commerce platform with growing attention to accessibility. Unlike WordPress, Shopify is a closed ecosystem with more control over the user experience, potentially allowing for more consistent accessibility implementation.
Shopify Theme Accessibility | Dawn Theme Analysis
Shopify’s default Dawn theme serves as their accessibility benchmark. Shopify has published a Voluntary Product Accessibility Template (VPAT) for the Dawn theme, documenting its conformance with WCAG standards.
According to Shopify’s documentation, Dawn theme includes accessibility features such as:
- Proper heading structure
- Keyboard navigation support
- ARIA attributes for dynamic content
- Sufficient color contrast in default color schemes
- Screen reader announcements for cart updates
However, the VPAT indicates that Dawn only “Partially Supports” some WCAG criteria, including Non-text Content (1.1.1). This suggests that even Shopify’s flagship theme doesn’t fully meet all accessibility requirements out of the box.
Shopify Admin Dashboard Accessibility
The Shopify merchant dashboard provides the interface for store management. Shopify has worked to make this experience more accessible, though public documentation about specific accessibility features is limited.
The admin interface includes:
- Keyboard navigation for major functions
- Screen reader compatibility for core features
- Consistent layout and navigation patterns
- Sufficient color contrast in most areas
However, the complexity of e-commerce management means that some advanced features may present accessibility challenges for merchants with disabilities.
Shopify Form and Checkout Accessibility
E-commerce success depends heavily on accessible forms, particularly during checkout. Shopify provides a standardized checkout experience that’s designed with accessibility in mind, though store owners have limited ability to customize it without affecting accessibility.
Shopify’s documentation emphasizes several key areas for form accessibility:
- Using clear labels connected to input fields using the <label> tag
- Ensuring smooth keyboard navigation with logical tab order
- Providing clear error messages with appropriate ARIA attributes
- Maintaining sufficient color contrast (at least 4.5:1 ratio for text)
- Supporting screen readers with ARIA attributes
Shopify’s checkout process is generally well-regarded for accessibility compared to many custom e-commerce solutions, though it’s not perfect. The standardized nature of Shopify’s checkout helps maintain consistency in accessibility, unlike WordPress where checkout experiences can vary dramatically based on plugins used.
E-commerce Feature Accessibility Comparison
When comparing WordPress (typically with WooCommerce) to Shopify for e-commerce accessibility, several key areas deserve attention.
Product Page Structure
Product pages are central to the shopping experience and need careful accessibility consideration.
WordPress/WooCommerce Product Pages:
- Structure depends heavily on the theme chosen
- Default WooCommerce templates provide basic accessibility features
- Customization can easily break accessibility if not carefully implemented
- Requires manual attention to ensure accessible product galleries, tabs, and variable product selections
Shopify Product Pages:
- Dawn theme provides a relatively accessible starting point
- Product images, variants, and add-to-cart functionality include basic accessibility features
- Recent accessibility focus has improved product page accessibility
- Common issues still exist, particularly with:
- Cart drawers missing proper focus management
- Inadequate keyboard support for product image galleries
- Missing alternative text for product images
A key advantage of Shopify is the standardization of core e-commerce elements, which helps maintain basic accessibility across stores. However, WordPress/WooCommerce offers more flexibility for implementing custom accessible solutions when needed.
Input Field Accessibility
Forms and input fields are critical for e-commerce interaction, from product searches to checkout information.
WordPress/WooCommerce Forms:
- Form accessibility varies widely based on theme and plugins used
- WooCommerce checkout forms have improved accessibility over time
- Form field validation and error messaging often need improvement
- Screen reader compatibility depends heavily on implementation
Shopify Forms:
- Standardized form elements with consistent markup
- Built-in validation with accessibility considerations
- Shopping cart forms tend to have better accessibility than product filters or search forms
- Focus management in forms still presents some challenges
According to testing documented in the search results, Shopify has made improving form accessibility a priority, with guidance for developers on implementing accessible input fields. Both platforms require attention to ensure forms meet WCAG requirements for labels, keyboard operation, and error identification.
Shopping Cart and Checkout Process
The path to purchase must be accessible for all users to avoid losing sales due to accessibility barriers.
WordPress/WooCommerce Checkout:
- Highly customizable, which can help or hurt accessibility
- Default templates provide basic accessibility features
- Third-party checkout plugins often introduce accessibility issues
- Requires careful testing after any customization
Shopify Checkout:
- More standardized experience with consistent accessibility features
- Limited customization options, which helps maintain accessibility
- Focus management in cart drawers needs improvement
- Error handling generally meets accessibility requirements
A significant accessibility challenge for both platforms is maintaining keyboard focus during dynamic updates like adding items to cart. Shopify’s documentation specifically highlights this as an issue to address, noting that “Cart drawers are a common pattern across e-commerce storefronts… While visually appealing, they can create accessibility barriers if not implemented correctly.”
Third-Party Extensions Impact on Accessibility
Both WordPress and Shopify rely heavily on third-party extensions to add functionality. These extensions can dramatically affect a site’s accessibility-for better or worse.
WordPress Plugin Ecosystem and Accessibility
WordPress has thousands of plugins that extend its functionality. The accessibility impact of these plugins varies dramatically:
- Many popular plugins have no documented accessibility testing
- Some larger plugins like WooCommerce have improved accessibility focus
- Accessibility-specific plugins can help remedy core issues
- Plugin conflicts often create unexpected accessibility problems
WordPress accessibility plugins fall into several categories:
- Testing tools: Plugins that help identify accessibility issues
- Remediation tools: Plugins that attempt to fix accessibility problems
- User interface enhancements: Plugins adding accessibility features like text resizing or contrast adjustment
Popular accessibility plugins mentioned in the search results include WP Accessibility, One Click Accessibility, and Accessibility Suite. However, these tools can’t fix all issues, particularly those deeply embedded in theme structure or other plugins.
According to WordPress accessibility experts, the best approach is selecting plugins with documented accessibility testing and commitment, rather than relying on remediation plugins to fix problems afterward.
Shopify App Marketplace and Accessibility
Shopify’s app ecosystem is more controlled than WordPress plugins but still presents accessibility challenges:
- Apps often add custom interfaces that may not follow accessibility best practices
- Overlapping functionality between apps can create confusing experiences for assistive technology users
- Some apps specifically focus on improving store accessibility
Shopify has been encouraging app developers to consider accessibility, but many apps still introduce barriers. Common accessibility issues from Shopify apps include:
- Inaccessible modal windows
- Custom form fields without proper labels
- Interactive elements that don’t support keyboard navigation
- Dynamic content updates without appropriate ARIA attributes
Comparing Dedicated Accessibility Solutions
Both platforms offer specialized accessibility solutions through their extension marketplaces:
WordPress Accessibility Solutions:
- Free plugins like WP Accessibility for addressing common issues
- Premium solutions that offer more comprehensive remediation
- Integration with testing tools for ongoing monitoring
Shopify Accessibility Solutions:
- Apps like Accessibility Enabler and Accessibly for automated fixes
- Solutions that add user interface controls for accessibility preferences
- Limited options for deep structural accessibility improvements
The search results mention several Shopify accessibility solutions: “Use apps like Accessibility Enabler AW or Accessibly for additional features”. These tools can help with surface-level accessibility improvements but don’t replace proper accessible design from the ground up.
For both platforms, third-party accessibility solutions should be viewed as supplements to, not replacements for, accessible design and development practices.
Making Your Choice | Accessibility Decision Factors
When deciding between WordPress and Shopify based on accessibility needs, consider these key factors:
Development Expertise Available:
- WordPress offers more control but requires more accessibility knowledge
- Shopify provides more guardrails but less flexibility to fix certain issues
Type of Website Needed:
- Content-heavy sites might benefit from WordPress’s publishing tools
- Pure e-commerce sites might find Shopify’s built-in features more accessible out of the box
Budget for Customization:
- WordPress may require more investment in accessibility expertise
- Shopify may limit what’s possible without Premium plans or custom storefronts
Ongoing Maintenance Concerns:
- WordPress requires vigilance during updates to maintain accessibility
- Shopify handles platform updates but may introduce changes affecting accessibility
Legal Compliance Requirements:
- Both platforms require additional work to guarantee legal compliance
- Neither platform automatically ensures ADA or other legal requirements are met
Whichever platform you choose, remember that accessibility is an ongoing process, not a one-time fix. Regular testing with real users and assistive technologies remains essential.se may come with additional costs beyond the base subscription.
Which Platform Wins for Accessibility in 2025?
After comparing WordPress and Shopify across multiple accessibility dimensions, there’s no clear overall winner-each platform has strengths and weaknesses when it comes to creating accessible websites.
WordPress strengths:
- Greater flexibility to implement custom accessible solutions
- Strong community focus on accessibility improvements
- Ability to fully customize all aspects of user experience
- Detailed accessibility documentation and guidelines
Shopify strengths:
- More standardized e-commerce components with baseline accessibility
- Consistent checkout experience with accessibility considerations
- Better default handling of dynamic e-commerce features
- Structured approach to theme accessibility testing
WordPress weaknesses:
- Inconsistent accessibility across themes and plugins
- Easier to accidentally break accessibility during customization
- Requires more expertise to maintain accessibility
- Admin interface still presents accessibility challenges
Shopify weaknesses:
- Limited ability to fix certain accessibility issues due to platform constraints
- Fewer options for specialized accessibility solutions
- Less control over checkout experience accessibility
- Third-party apps often introduce accessibility barriers
The truth is that both platforms require additional work to create truly accessible websites. The best choice depends on your specific needs, resources, and technical capabilities.
For businesses with accessibility expertise and needing maximum flexibility, WordPress offers more control to implement accessible solutions. For those wanting a more standardized e-commerce experience with less technical maintenance, Shopify provides a more consistent starting point.update content frequently, while content-heavy sites with stable information might benefit more from UserWay’s page-view based pricing model.
Using Automated Tools for Quick Insights (Accessibility-Test.org Scanner)
Automated testing tools provide a fast way to identify many common accessibility issues. They can quickly scan your website and point out problems that might be difficult for people with disabilities to overcome.
Visit Our Tools Comparison Page!
Run a FREE scan to check compliance and get recommendations to reduce risks of lawsuits
Final Thoughts
Regardless of platform, remember that accessible websites benefit everyone. Online stores with proper accessibility see up to 23% higher revenue on average. Beyond legal compliance, accessibility is about opening your digital doors to the widest possible audience-something both WordPress and Shopify can help you achieve with the right approach and attention to detail.
Want More Help?
Try our free website accessibility scanner to identify heading structure issues and other accessibility problems on your site. Our tool provides clear recommendations for fixes that can be implemented quickly.
Join our community of developers committed to accessibility. Share your experiences, ask questions, and learn from others who are working to make the web more accessible.